Papa Gino’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• Sandra S.

  star star star star star 7 June 2026

  After having a bad experience at the Seabrook location (that is now closed), I was hesitant to try a papa Gino's again, especially with lots of locations closing lately. I'm glad I gave this one a shot, however, as it reminded me of what I loved about me and my mom's monthly papa Gino's trips we used to take as I was growing up.
  
  Papa Gino's pizza's taste is actually my favorite, because the sauce tastes the best to me. It's not as sweet as some other places (like Nicks Place in Salisbury MA) and the cheese is more plentiful/evenly coated then some places in which the sauce seeps through the thinner cheese layer (like Pizza Hut). Another thing I always liked about Papa Gino's is that their Parmesan cheese bottles are right out in the open for anyone to use, as opposed to some more mom and pop pizza places that keep the cheese behind the counter so you need to go up and ask.
  
  What I liked about this location specifically (besides actually making sure my order was input and made after I ordered it, unlike the seabrook location) was how friendly the server was. In the Seabrook location, the employees always seemed like they either didn't want to be there, or were more interested in rushing your order than getting you what you'd like to eat. At this location, the woman who took our order seemed relaxed and happy. Our food came out really quickly, and was so hot I had to wait a little while for it to cool down before I could dig in.
  
  I also like how this location closes at 11pm on Saturday and Friday, making it a great late night option as the food shouldn't take longer than 30 minutes to come out (it's fast casual food rather than a traditional restaurant experience).

• Jill M.

  star star star star star_border 6 June 2026

  About once a week, I call in my order on my way home from work. All but two times my order was ready. Love the sauce flavor and this is one of my favorite pizzas and speghetti and meatballs. Two times my order was messed up was due to new employees and they apologized and offered a complementary order of cinnamon sticks. I also like that you get free bread sticks when the Patriots win (which has been every week)!

• Qi G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  The wait time was long. I ordered 2 slices and had to wait about 20 minutes. The pizza was also disgustingly greasy and made my stomach hurt afterwards. Even with a giant wad of tissue, i could not soak up all the oil. Do yourself a huge favor and just go next door to Dunkin Donuts for a sandwich instead....

• Denise C.

  star star star star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Just picked up a small pizza for my 2yr old son and I. Perfect size for us. On your way home from work an easy decision..

• Mr. B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  Hahaha going going going- gone.
  
  Papa is dead and there is no saving him.
  The only good reviews for this place are either from paid reviewers or the retarded that give everyone five stars.
  
  Soon this place will be closed finally.  Papa will be done ripping everyone off with their nasty greasy overpriced and late to the table food.
  
  We will all miss the real papa but he left us in 1992 when an evil corporation took over and ran it into the ground- throwing everything that made papa special into the trash, including the thick pan pizza which was it's best selling pizza.
  
  Forever gone but always remembered- RIP Papa